Search Results
Search this site
5067 results found with an empty search
- CP&DR News Briefs Nov. 17, 2026: Esmeralda Approved; Marina Safeway; Data Centers; and More
This article is brought to you courtesy of the paying subscribers to California Planning & Development Report. You can subscribe to CP&DR by clicking here. You can sign up for CP&DR’s free weekly newsletter here. Esmeralda New Urbanist Community Wins Approval in Cloverdale The Cloverdale City Council approved, on a 4-0 vote, the Esmeralda project, including adopting Esmeralda Specific Plan, an addendum to a previously certified environmental impact report and amendments to the city’s General Plan to accommodate the largest and most controversial development proposed in northern Sonoma County in decades. The vote followed over 3 hours of public debate that ended around 11 p.m. The 261 acre site is now approved for 605 housing units, a 160-room resort hotel, restaurants, office space, daycare, athletic fields and a K-6 school. The remaining 123 acres would be preserved as undeveloped open space. Developers say it would deliver more than $4 million a year to a city of 9,000 that has struggled economically since a Highway 101 bypass diverted downtown traffic in 1994. However, opponents fear that by leaning on an addendum to an earlier EIR rather than a fresh review, the city has failed to ensure the former Masonite wood-preserving plant and Louisiana-Pacific sawmill site will be properly cleaned of petroleum hydrocarbons, pentachlorophenol and other contaminants. (See related CP&DR coverage.) SB 2011 Enables San Francisco to Approve Marina Safeway Towers The controversial Marina Safeway project, which will replace a nearly 70-year-old Safeway with a new grocery store and residential development, will go forward. The city followed 2022’s Senate Bill 2011, a streamlining law that applies to certain residential developments in commercial zones. SB 2011 allowed supervisors to bypass further public hearings and CEQA review that typically accompany major developments. The expedited approval came as opponents continue to challenge the fast-tracked process in court. The redevelopment would replace the existing Safeway with a mixed-use complex featuring two towers of 18 and 22 stories, a new Safeway and 848 homes. Project developer Align declined to announce whether it has secured financing or when construction could begin. Despite rising housing prices, large-scale housing construction has been largely frozen in the city for years. (See related CP&DR coverage.) Data Center Update: San Francisco, Sacramento, Fairfield San Francisco is considering a 10- month extension on their data center moratorium after a city report found that data centers threaten an already limited electricity capacity in the city. Data centers would compete for electricity with housing, hospitals, businesses and other developments while backup generators contribute to noise and air pollution in neighborhoods already bearing environmental consequences. The report found that while the city is already nearing its transmission capacity, a single 50-megawatt data center could consume as much electricity as 25,000 new homes. In Sacramento, Blackstone subsidiary Link Logistics is planning a 300-megawatt “hyperscale” data center at Depot Park, a former military site. The Sacramento Municipal Utility District has sought over $120 million from the U.S. Department of Energy to support the proposed site, pitching Sacramento as a “premier destination” for AI data centers despite the fact that the city doesn’t have data centers and has discussed moratoriums. Though the city has not received a formal application, several elected officials have met with Link Logistics in recent months, though the company has declined to comment on the environmental and economic impacts of the project on the community. The Fairfield City Council will consider an initial 45-day moratorium on accepting, processing or approving applications and permits for large data centers following public concern about electricity, water, noise and air pollution. NorthPoint Development is also eyeing a nearly 33-acre site near the Vacaville border for a data center. No formal application has been filed, and NorthPoint’s inquiries were described as routine due diligence on land it hopes to buy from Canon Partners LLC. Oceanside Runs Afoul of SB 79 The Department of Housing and Community Development has found that Oceanside is not compliant with the new Senate Bill 79, which allows buildings up to 95 feet tall near certain transit stops regardless of local zoning. In June, Oceanside’s City Council unanimously passed an ordinance exempting or deferring wide swaths of land near seven transit stops, just before the law passed in July. An Oct. 15 letter from the state found that the city failed to document that exempted sites lack good walking access to transit, excluded sites zoned for homes, mixed use or commercial, exempted wetlands (which the law does not allow), and did not document existing housing capacity. (See related CP&DR coverage.) CP&DR Coverage: SB 344 Sets New Precedent for CEQA Exemptions SB 344, signed by Gov. Newsom, is designed to move forward the big “Midway Rising” mixed-use infill project near San Diego International Airport. To my knowledge, this is the first time the Legislature has simply waved CEQA aside in this way and it’s reasonable to assume that most big, influential projects will run to the Legislature to get similar CEQA relief in the future. By no means does SB 344 constitute the end of CEQA. But it may well be just another CEQA death rattle – and it’s one that’s likely to favor large projects with strong political backing. Little guys will still have to worry about CEQA. But for the big guys, CEQA may no longer be much of an obstacle. Quick Hits & Updates The Department of Housing and Community Development has created the Housing Entitlement Guide to help developers, local governments and advocates get homes approved faster and with fewer roadblocks. The guide explains how key state laws work together, including the Permit Streamlining Act, the Housing Accountability Act and the Housing Crisis Act, helping constituents navigate California’s 540 individual zoning codes for each city, towns and county in the state. Great America amusement park in Santa Clara will close in September 2027 after over 50 years of service. In 2022, owner Cedar Fair sold the 112-acre land to industrial real estate company Prologis for $310 million, mostly to pay down debt. The property, one of the largest parcels in Silicon Valley, is expected to be redeveloped. Days before the recent election, outgoing LA Mayor Karen Bass issued Executive Directive No. 26, which orders city agencies to begin building a universal affordable housing search tool and one common application. The housing department will look into requiring owners of properties built with city funding to list open units on a city registry that utilizes a standard application. It will include search filters, maps, automated match alerts, in-person application help at libraries and senior centers, and public “teach-ins” to help residents avoid online scams. The California Coastal Commission approved two amendments to ease housing constraints on the San Mateo County coast. In Half Moon Bay, the rezoning allows higher residential densities on 10 properties, workforce housing on four others, and staff-level approval of qualifying affordable projects on 14 sites without public hearings. In unincorporated Midcoast communities, the changes allowed San Mateo County to access unused permit capacity from past years to ease a housing permit backlog. The backlog was triggered by the Cypress Point project in Moss Beach, which left room for only 18 more units through 2027 and could have delayed approvals until 2031. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has until April 30, 2027 to determine the California spotted owl’s eligibility for protection under the Endangered Species Act after a lawsuit from the Center for Biological Diversity. The owl’s range includes broad swaths of California’s coastal mountains and the Sierra Nevada. U.S. District Judge Eumi K. Lee rejected the center’s proposed deadline of Nov. 19, 2026 to avoid a rushed timeline, and rejected the service’s argument that it couldn’t finish before May 10, 2028. The Strategic Growth Council approved $60.5 million in grants for 40 housing and climate projects representing 36 state tribes. Most of the money ($52 million) will be awarded to 19 tribes through the new Tribal Pre-Development Housing Fund, covering planning, site preparation and infrastructure costs to support about 900 homes. The remaining $8.5 million funds 21 capacity-building grants for housing, such as climate adaptation planning and traditional land management. The City of Los Angeles is banning new oil and gas drilling throughout the city and creating a 20-year plan to phase out existing wells. The city passed a similar ban in 2022, but a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge struck it down in 2024 after a lawsuit by Warren Resources, E&B Natural Resources and Hillcrest Beverly Oil Corp. Supporters say the measure is a step toward ending drilling in neighborhoods that have long borne its health impacts, while industry critics argue that bans complicate supply rather than decrease demand. According to California Energy Commission data, foreign oil now makes up roughly 61% of the state’s supply, up from under 10% three decades ago. The Sonoma Marin Area Rail Transit Board of Directors approved a $190.5 million contract, including $162 million in state grants, with the joint venture Stacy and Witbeck/Herzog to build nearly five miles of rail from Windsor to Healdsburg. The work includes restoring the derelict track segment, adding a modern train control system, and creating two steel bridges that will also carry bike and pedestrian traffic. Construction is expected to begin in spring 2027, and service to Healdsburg is projected for late 2028 at an estimated total cost of $269 million.
- How Far Upstream Does A CEQA Analysis Have To Go?
In an expansive decision, a Kern County judge has ruled that the environmental impact report for the state’s first carbon capture project must cover not only the carbon capture project itself but also the sources of the carbon to be captured, including cement production and oil field activities.
- County Approves Housing Element 3 Years Late -- But Must Pay $300,000 and Deal Wit 0 Builders Remedy Applications
Three years latr and under a threat from Attorney General Rob Bonta, Monterey County has finally adopted its 6th cycle housing element. But as part of a settlement agreement with Bonta, the county must pay $300,000 into a housing trust fund. And the county still must deal with nine builders remedy applications, including one from the same business using a builders remedy approach to an apartment building adjacent to the Santa Barbara Mission.
- CP&DR News Briefs: November 10, 2026: Fresno Expansion; Huntington Beach Housing; GHG Reductions; and more
This article is brought to you courtesy of the paying subscribers to California Planning & Development Report. You can subscribe to CP&DR by clicking here. You can sign up for CP&DR’s free weekly newsletter here. Fresno Council Tables Massive Expansion In a surprise move, the Fresno City Council indefinitely postponed a vote on the long-planned and fiercely debated expansion known as the Southeast Development Area (SEDA). Six of seven council members voted for the postponement in a closed session prior to the council’s regular meeting; a public discussion and the actual vote to approve the project had been on the council’s agenda. First envisioned in 2006, SEDA would have opened 9,000 acres to annexation and development, consisting of up to 45,000 homes and upwards of $4 billion in investment. The plan had drawn opposition from labor groups, the Fresno Unified School District, and many residents, mainly over concerns that the development would unduly strain city services. Last week’s election included victories by anti-SEDA city council candidates, so even an approval surely would have been overturned once new councilmembers were installed. The council’s decision preserves the opportunity to bring the plan, or a modified version thereof, up for a vote at a later date. (See related CP&DR coverage.) Court Upholds and Adds to Huntington Beach’s Housing Element Penalties Huntington Beach is facing at least $160,000 in fines and $50,000 in additional monthly penalties after a judge found their updated housing plan still in violation of state law. under a tentative ruling issued Oct. 29 by San Diego Superior Court Judge Katherine Bacal. In August, the California Department of Housing and Development sent a letter expressing concern that the city had not completed the zoning changes needed to carry out the plan, which was approved in June and would allow over 13,000 units by the end of the decade. San Diego Superior Court Judge Katherine Bacal had previously suspended the accumulating fines in June after the plan was approved. Under state law, the city had until October 14 to implement the rezones, which HCD says didn’t happen. The judge had earlier set a $10,000 monthly late fee from January through May, with the amount slated to rise to $50,000 afterward. In the new ruling, fines were set at $20,000 a month for June through August and $50,000 from September on, to accommodate HCD’s delay in reporting their findings. The fines go to a state trust that funds affordable housing and homeownership programs. The city plans to appeal at their November 6 meeting. Reductions in Greenhouse Gas Emissions Progressing Slowly At the current pace, California won’t reach its greenhouse gas emissions target until 2034 and is far off-pace to meet its 2045 goals. That’s the conclusion of the most recent greenhouse gas emissions inventory and the topic of a recent conference in Los Angeles marking the 20th anniversary of Assembly Bill 32. Adopted in 2006, AB 32 set the first legally mandated emissions targets in the nation. The state returned to its 1990 emissions levels, about 431 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent. Despite strides, the state is falling behind in other goals. Emissions fell about 4% in 2024 to 346 million metric tons, leaving the state roughly halfway to its 2030 goal of 260 million. The state is falling far behind its 2045 goal of 65 million metric tons, and according to data will require cuts of about 8.8% per year starting in 2030, more than double the current rate. Still, the 2024 drop was the largest annual reduction outside the pandemic and recession years, driven by cleaner transportation and electricity, more electric vehicles and appliances, and more wind and solar power. Transportation remains the largest source of emissions, and officials say federal actions are making it harder. The Trump administration has ended EV rebates, revoked tailpipe rules, and challenged the state’s EV sales target, though these effects aren’t yet visible in the data. Study: High Housing Costs Force Californians to Delay Homeownership A study by the Public Policy Institute of California found that Californians wait longer to become homeowners more than people almost anywhere in the country. The current homeownership rate sits around 56%, just above New York, which currently has the lowest homeownership rate in the country at 54%. The rate in the rest of the country hovers around 66%. In California, homeowners don’t become the majority until the late 40s, so most working-age Californians are renting. Fifteen years ago, half of Californians owned a home by age 39; now the average age sits at 47, closely following the state’s rising housing costs. White and Asian Californians reach majority homeownership earlier than Black and Latino Californians, mirroring long-standing income and wealth gaps. Homeownership is still the largest source of wealth for middle-income families, so a later average age leaves Californians less time to build equity before retirement. The state is also facing a growing number of people in their 60s and 70s still paying a mortgage or renting. CP&DR Coverage: Cities Face Lawsuits over SB 79 Compliance Foreshadowing a major legal battle, housing advocates have filed five SB 79 lawsuits around the state, including two in San Diego. Perhaps most significantly, Californians For Homeownership, the nonprofit legal arm of the California Association of Realtors, and various YIMBY law groups have challenged the methodology used by the San Diego Association of Governments in determining which station areas to include in its SB 79 maps. As CP&DR previously reported, SANDAG’s methodology had the effect of eliminating Solana Beach Station and downgrading the Oceanside Transit Center – North County San Diego’s biggest transit center – from Tier 1 to Tier 2 under SB 79. Elsewhere, Californians For Homeownership sued the City of San Diego and the City of Oceanside over the way they interpreted state law about pedestrian access, the City of San Francisco over the way it defined industrial hubs, and the City of Montebello over its moratorium on SB 79 projects. Quick Hits & Updates Santa Monica released a draft plan to transform its 200-acre airport property into a large public park after the airport closes on December 31, 2028. Design firm Sasaki has created a plan that includes sports fields, a dog park, wildflower meadow, arboretum, recreation center, and spaces for food and cultural events. Existing buildings would be preserved and converted into approximately 500,000 square feet of leasable space to help generate revenue. Environmental reviews are expected between 2027 and 2028, with detailed planning and construction to follow depending on funding timelines. The San Diego City Council’s Land Use and Housing Committee has endorsed the Midway Rising development, sending the proposal to the full city council next month. The original plan outlined a mixed-use development featuring 2,000 affordable homes, about 2,250 market-rate apartments, a new 16,000-seat entertainment venue, 14.5 acres of parks and 130,000 square feet of retail and restaurant space on the site of the 48-acre Pechanga Arena. Questions still remain in the agreement over whether all 2,000 affordable units will be newly created or whether developers of nearby projects could pay Midway Rising to satisfy their own affordable housing obligations. The Coastal Commission approved changes to South Coast Water District’s proposed $296 million desalination project near Doheny State Beach, moving ocean-water intake wells away from the campground to the beach’s northern day-use area. The facility is designed to produce up to 5 million gallons of drinking water daily, reducing South Orange County’s reliance on imported water which currently accounts for about 90% of its supply. The Sierra Club has sued the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, alleging that the agency overstated future water demand to justify increased water diversions, infrastructure spending and potentially higher customer rates. The lawsuit seeks revisions to the city’s Urban Water Management Plan, which projects water demand will rise 17% for San Francisco residents and 14% for wholesale customers by 2050. The Sierra Club argues these projections overestimate actual demand by roughly one-third and could lead to unnecessary environmental harm along the Tuolumne River. The California High-Speed Rail Authority’s board voted 7-2 to limit CEO Ian Choudri’s contracting authority after a state investigation uncovered $600,000 in questionable consultant travel expenses. Investigators found consultants from four firms billed taxpayers for expenses including first-class flights, luxury rides and trips to restaurants and other venues, while agency staff failed to adequately review many requests. The board now requires in-house attorneys to review new and existing contracts, while the agency has suspended travel payments to the four firms and is seeking to recover questionable expenses. The San Diego Foundation announced a $100 million financing partnership with Bear Creek Fund Advisors to accelerate construction of affordable workforce housing across San Diego. The announcement comes at the same time as the groundbreaking of Louisiana Street, a 38-unit development in North Park, which will offer studio apartments affordable to residents earning up to 80% of the area median income. The project is the first of four planned developments in North Park and Normal Heights that will collectively deliver 257 affordable homes. The California Coastal Commission certified Pismo Beach’s updated coastal land-use plan after rejecting the original proposal unanimously and approving it with modifications. The revised plan covers about six miles of coastline and strengthens protections for sensitive habitats, public beach access and affordable housing.
- Ballot Measure Results: Cities Cautiously Embrace Development
For all the disparities among jurisdictions and electorates across the state, the fundamental question that can be asked collectively of local land-use ballot measures in any given election is, how do Californians feel about development?
- It's Back To Swiss-Cheese CEQA
For all the things that were wrong with Proposition 45, it did at least have this going for it: It might have cut down on the Swiss-cheese approach to the California Environmental Quality Act.
- Ballot Measures Updated: S.F. Housing Measure, Transfer Tax Measure Approved
Some of the hot takes following last Tuesday's election insisted that San Francisco—home of the Beats, hippies, Harvey Milk, and Byzantine development processes—no longer deserves to call itself "progressive." These proclamations stem in large part from voters' sentiments on two land use measures (among five other, unrelated measures on the city ballot): Prop. A, a bond measure to pay for low-income and assisted living housing, and Prop. C, a measure to exempt certain commercial transactions from paying a transfer tax.
- Ballot Measure Roundup: Some Measures Could Roll Back Voter Approval Requirement
On local ballots, 2026 may go down as the year of the meta-election. Rather than voting directly on cities’ land-use changes, many electorates are voting on the ability to vote on land-use changes.
- CP&DR News Briefs: November 3, 2026: Feds vs. Coastal; S.F. Vacancy Tax; Planning Grants; and More
This article is brought to you courtesy of the paying subscribers to California Planning & Development Report. You can subscribe to CP&DR by clicking here. You can sign up for CP&DR’s free weekly newsletter here. Trump Administration Advances Plan to Undermine Coastal Protections The Trump administration has issued draft findings from a federal review that would strip California of its authority to protect its coastline unless state regulators agree to more than a dozen “corrective actions.” The 92-page review, produced by NOAA’s Office for Coastal Management and obtained by the Times through a public records request, accuses California coastal authorities of “regulatory overreach” and bias against offshore drilling, oil and gas projects, and SpaceX’s launch activities. It also suspends federal funding for the state’s coastal management program until the shortfalls are addressed. The demands include that the Coastal Commission meet with SpaceX and with Sable Offshore Corp., a Texas oil company seeking to restart an offshore operation near Santa Barbara. The state must also issue a statement by January pledging not to categorically oppose initiatives tied to certain industries, such as oil and gas, or activities such as offshore drilling. Court Strikes Down San Francisco’s Voter-Approved “Empty Homes Tax” San Francisco’s “Empty Homes Tax” was denied by a San Francisco Superior court judge, determined to be an illegal taking of property that violates owners’ privacy rights under the California constitution. The “Empty Homes Tax” or Proposition M passed in 2022 by a 54.5% margin. The tax would have charged owners of buildings with three or more units for any dwelling left unoccupied for at least 182 days of the prior year, starting in 2025 at $2,500 to $5,000 per unit depending on size. By 2027 owners of the smallest units would be charged up to $10,000 annually, those owners of units over 2,000 square feet would be charged $20,000 per "unoccupied" unit. Unoccupied unit fees would also have applied to units occupied by family members and to units an owner was actively marketing but couldn’t rent. Supporters said the measure would push landlords to lease available units in order to address the city’s housing shortage. Opponents of the bill argued it infringed on their right to manage their own property. SGC Solicits Proposals for Climate-Oriented Planning Grants The Strategic Growth Council has issued a Request for Proposals seeking a provider to deliver Implementation Technical Assistance (TA) to grantees of its Transformative Climate Communities (TCC) and Community Resilience Centers (CRC) programs. The TA program was created to assist TCC and CRC Grantee Teams in several areas, including completing funded work and meeting program requirements and strengthening grant management and project implementation skills. Providers will also be expected to tailor TA services to each team’s unique needs and context and expand grantees’ knowledge of climate resilience and sustainable community development. Data Center Update: Restrictions in Gilroy, San Diego; Nationwide, Opposition Has Blocked $130 Billion Worth of Development On a unanimous council vote, the City of Gilroy extended its ban until Sept. 3, 2027 after an Amazon data center was allowed to proceed without public input, and San Diego’s council voted 9-0 for an extendable 45-day moratorium with a stakeholder working group and principles such as no added costs for ratepayers and 100% renewable energy. Other San Diego County cities have gone further, including Poway which banned large AI data centers and Escondido which extended its moratorium through August 2027. San Jose is opting for uniform development standards rather than a pause, though residents say that drafts have so far fallen short. So far, most existing projects are exempt, such as Gilroy’s Amazon site and the NAVWAR site in San Diego on federal land. A recent policy report from the Lincoln Institute of Land Use Policy on data center development found that community opposition blocked or delayed 75 projects worth $130 billion nationwide in just the first quarter of 2026, arguing that data centers have yet to earn a “social license to operate”, or widespread approval by the general public, and that in order to move forward, local officials need specialized planning frameworks rather than relying on outdated land use rules. California cities are responding with moratoriums that buy time to write those rules in order to protect neighborhoods from noise, environmental impact and community interference. (See related CP&DR coverage.) CP&DR Coverage: End of an Era in Sacramento Tom Pace joined the City of Sacramento's Planning Division back in 1997. In the years since then, Sacramento and Pace -- who took over long-range planning in 2006 and became planning director in 2017 (after a brief stint in Stockton) and community development director in 2020 -- embraced an enthusiastically pro-housing ethos, with policies to match. Perhaps most notably, he led one of the most dramatic upzoning efforts in state history when the city effectively made development of small multifamily dwellings in all residential areas. Having retired in May (succeeded by assistant Community Development Director Matt Hertel), Pace spoke with CP&DR's Josh Stephens about his service to the state's capital city--which is, arguably, much more of a city than it was 29 years ago. Quick Hits & Updates Governor Newsom announced that California’s Proposition 1-backed Homekey+ program has so far awarded 2,905 permanent supportive homes since launching in 2024, including 828 for veterans. The latest round adds $115.2 million for five projects with 329 homes in Yuba City, San Francisco, Riverside County, Lompoc (Santa Barbara County), and Los Angeles County. Of the new homes, 168 will be reserved for veterans. So far, awards from Homekey+ and the earlier Homekey program have funded homes serving more than 200,000 Californians. The Housing Development and Finance Committee (HDFC) released its second set of draft regulations, now open for public comment until November 17, 2026. During the first round of feedback, HDFC received more than 1,800 comments, and revisions addressing these have aimed to simplify programs, speed up funding, increase transparency and equity, and deliver complete capital financing stacks. Advocates for incorporating Castro Valley (Alameda County) are pushing for a new cityhood vote, projected for March 2028, more than two decades after 72% of voters rejected incorporation in 2002. Supporters of the vote such as the Town of Castro Valley (TCV) say the difference this time is a realistic first-year budget that yields a surplus. Proponents argue that lacking city status has cost the community more than $14 million in grants that went to surrounding cities. Incorporation could also give residents, rather than the city, control over zoning, development, and the timing of infrastructure repairs. A Los Angeles County-commissioned study found that closing Whiteman Airport in Pacoima could cost WHO up to $3.5 billion, including $3.46 billion in redevelopment costs and $90 million for demolition and cleanup. The $2.1 million study evaluated three potential paths for the future, including maintaining the existing airport with improvements, retaining airport operations while allowing development, or closing the airport for redevelopment. Sonoma County is set to lift a ban on ADUs in areas with specific zoning designations to expand affordable housing opportunities while maintaining safeguards for water, wastewater, fire safety, and traffic concerns. Nearly 4,000 additional properties in unincorporated areas starting November 5 will be allowed to add granny units, in-law units and backyard cottages. The change follows state pressure to remove zoning restrictions that conflict with California housing laws.
- Cities Tussle With HCD Over SB 79 Implementation
Cities around the state continue to tussle with the California Department of Housing and Community Development over implementation of SB 79, with HCD approving some city plans and actions and rejecting others. In particular, HCD has concluded that actions by Beverly Hills, Burlingame, Pasadena, and Oceanside are out of compliance with the new law. Beverly Hills and Burlingame must respond to HCD’s non-compliance letters by this week, while Pasadena’s deadline is late November and Oceanside’s deadline is mid-December. As CP&DR previously reported, Beverly Hills is expected to rescind its SB 79 alternative plan, which HCD has rejected. Passed last year and hailed by YIMBYs are a major step forward, SB 79 essentially requires midrise (4- to 8-story) zoning around major rail transit stations in urban counties around the state. But cities have the option of excluding some properties, either permanently (no walking path of less than one mile to the stop; industrial employment hubs) or temporarily until about a year after the 7th-cycle Housing Element (sites already zoned for at least 50% of SB 79 capacity; certain low-resource areas; very high fire hazard zones; locally designated historic resources; one-foot sea-level-rise areas). Cities also have the option of adopting an alternative plan that moves the required density around, so long as no parcel has less than 50% or more than 200% of the density required by SB 79. The HCD issues are separate from issues raised by lawsuits filed by various prohousing groups, especially in San Diego, which include questioning how SANDAG drew the SB 79 maps and how both San Diego and Oceanside defined a walkable path to teh transit station. (Previous CP&DR cover of these lawsutis can be found here.) Among the most contentious questions is whether density bonuses can be permitted on top of SB 79 densities. Denus bonus law can increase densities 50-100% above base zoning. San Francisco, Beverly Hills, and Burlingame all argued that density bonuses should not be permitted in SB 79 areas under their alternative plans. But HCD disagreed, arguing that because of alternative plan “is part of a local jurisdiction’s municipal code, other state housing laws apply that operate independently of” the alternative plan, including density bonus law. Thus, according to HCD’s interpretation, a developer could seek additional density on top of the SB 79 zoning by invoking the density bonus law. But HCD did not handle these three situations the same. In finding San Francisco’s alternative plan compliant with state law – the first jurisdiction to receive that status – HCD said that the city could not enforce the municipal code section that prohibits the use of density bonus law in SB 79 areas, though the agency require that the code section be deleted. In the Beverly Hills case, HCD raised this concern in a findings letter in early September, using the same language that was used in the San Francisco letter. But, unlike in the San Franciscocase, HCD ordered Beverly Hills to remove the density bonus language from its municipal code. HCD imposed the same requirement on Burlingame in a findings letter issued the same day. In its staff report (which can be accessed through a meeting agenda here), Beverly Hills staff planners claimed that HCD reversed its position on the density bonus issue. Pasadens excluded a large number of properties, including an Edison right-of-way near the Sierra Madre Village transit station, but HCD objected. But density bonuses are not the only issue bringing cities into conflict with HCD. Several other issues have arisen that indicate HCD is taking an extremely hard line in reviewing local plans and ordinances related to SB 79, including calling for land zoned for parks to be included in some cases if the parks zoning allows some commercial use. In the Beverly Hills case, HCD disputed the city’s calculation of the zoned capacity under its alternative plan. HCD said the city did not subject existing units from the zoned capacity in the alternative plan. Either way, the alternative plan calls for a capacity of between 18,000 and 22,000 units in a city that currently has about 16,000 units. In Burlingame, in addition to the density bonus dispute, HCD has rejected the city’s decision to exclude land zoned for parks and public institutions, saying residential use is permitted in those zones under SB 79. A similar dispute occurred in Pasadena, where HCD rejected the city’s decision to exclude some non-residential zones, including an open space zone near the Sierra Madre Villa light-rail station. But the non-residential use is embedded in the general plan, whereas HCD looked to the underlying zoning. The open space zone, which consists mostly of a Southern California Edison right-of-way and a wash, allows some commercial uses, apparently because nurseries formerly existed on the Edison property. That opened the door for HCD to dispute the exclusion of the property. “While the statute does not explicitly define “mixed” or “commercial” uses, if the jurisdiction’s zoning district principally or conditionally permits residential, residential mixed use, or commercial land use on a parcel within a TOD zone over which the jurisdiction has zoning authority, then SB 79 shall apply,” HCD wrote in a September 25 letter to Pasadena. Many of the same issues arose in Oceanside, including the same netting out of existing units that Beverly Hills dealt with and parks and institutional zoning permitting commercial use, thus opening the door for SB 79. More significant is the fact that Oceanside sought to exclude the Oceanside Transit Center – the biggest transit center in North County San Diego – because it is a low-resource area. In an October 15 letter, HCD said it could not determine whether the area was in fact low resource. Oceanside has apparently been resisting SB 79 densities at the transit center in part because it has a plan for the area that limits development to 86 units per acre, a plan that has been approved by the Coastal Commission. HCD’s SB 79 letters, along with other technical assistance and enforcement letters, can be found here.
- CP&DR Vol. 41 No. 10 October 2026 Report
Subscribers -Log In to read the CP&DR Vol. 41 No. 10 October 2026 Report
- Position Available, Senior Planner, City of Carlsbad, CA
The City of Carlsbad is currently seeking a full time Senior Planner. Closing Date: Nov 17, 2026




